So I watched tonight's Canadian Idol -- which is a carbon copy of American Idol, except that instead of Ryan Seacrest they have Ben Mulroney, who is the telegenic son of former Conservative Prime Minister Brian Mulroney, so it's like if Ron Reagan Jr. hosted American Idol instead of a crappy talk show. And they have no Paula equivalent, because everyone else who mixes that many pills with that much booze is dead. But those aren't the only differences. I noticed Canadian Idol lacks some of AI's coldhearted cruelty -- like if the Canadians show you a little sad backstory on some teenager with a dream in her heart who sings while taking care of her ailing granny and whose father sold his teeth to buy her plane ticket to the auditions, you don't have to worry -- she's in. Whereas on AI, they'd occasionally pull the tugging-heartstrings fakeout. "She's just a poor kid with a dream ... that's not gonna come true! Sucks to be you!" Also on CA, and to me this speaks very highly of the quality of teenagers they grow up here, there's none of that backtalk. When the judges informed contestants that they were very, very bad singers, there was none of this, "You don't know NOTHIN'! I'm gonna be a STAR and then you're gonna be sorry!" They just cried a little and left, which I found very refreshing. The sense of entitlement among really awful singers is one of the more alarming aspects of AI, and I'm tempted to blame the well-intentioned but overboard self-esteem movement in American education.
I can only guess what surprises await on Canada's Next Top Model. Perhaps the models are not functionally illiterate, as they are in the U.S. version? Perhaps when they are told that ALL they have to do in a given week is memorize three lines of text, one of which is invariably "Easy, breezy, beautiful -- Cover Girl," they actually are able to accomplish the task? Ah, the suspense of reality TV -- thank you Canada!
